Post by D. Nonymous on Jun 23, 2016 14:37:46 GMT -5
Coming from a martial arts background, this is a title that I hate to see again. In the Chinese martial arts the title "grand master" is tossed around quite a bit. The title in an of it's self has been used to describe great practitioners through out the years. But it has also been given to the unskilled, unscrupulous, and/or inexperienced. I have come to have a very adversarial relation ship with this term.
And for all it's popularity. It's complete bull****. The baggage associated with the term is plentiful. While in it's most benign form, it is a term of respect and adulation used for a specific teacher. However, the title has no objective meaning.
Add to this that I had learned that "master" is used in Kung fu as a verb, not a noun. Trying to master something. The term Sifu or Shifu does not translate to "master". Nor does Laoshi, Sigung or any other of the terms most associated with Kung Fu. A master is what you call another person. For face, respect, etc. But the true terms are terms of family (Father, brother, uncle...). Grandmaster doe snot fit well into that paradigm.
But, what is your view? Are there true grandmasters out there? If so, when does one start using the title? Is it ever ok to use the title yourself?
Not a fan personally. Also from Chinese martial arts, my view is that many, many people claim the title of Master to bring in students, so then other schools start calling their own teacher a grandmaster, to try to place them in a hierarchy. It's all PR and BS, essentially. I've met or trained with a few what I would consider top of the game practitioners. Usually they are the humblest you'll ever find. My first teacher, who I've seen called a grand master in tournament promotional materials, only let us call him shifu or coach.
That aside, just to argue semantics...how can a skill be grand mastered? If you've mastered something, aren't you kind of done progressing? Most real "masters" admit that they are continually learning, and will be until they die. To say that you've mastered something like a martial art is a bit preposterous and / or arrogant. Then to say you've grand mastered it?
Last Edit: Jun 23, 2016 18:35:06 GMT -5 by Wingrave
Post by Nero Attoru on Jun 24, 2016 8:40:13 GMT -5
I'll bring a little SW lore into this, the title of Grandmaster is actually the head of the Jedi Order at various points. Yoda held the position for many years... and I always thought it was incredibly stupid. The humble little Jedi Master we met in ESB would never put himself above the rest of his Order. Everything he teaches is completely against the concept. And what was the point, all in all? It's not like it gave him any weight in deciding matters - his wisdom was what did that. The other Masters respected him because of his experience and intelligence, not because of a title. In the end, they all worked as a Council anyway.
There are other titles that I find fun which have more function, but Grandmaster as a rank just seems silly for anyone in our hobby. Plus it's always hard to use a title like that and not sound like you're full of yourself...
Personally, I think the title of Grandmaster should be simply a formality. It makes sense to have a face for an organization, and to have some form of tie breaker in case of indecision by the organization. Giving a special title to the one this honor is awarded to makes sense, rather than having implied leaders or something even sillier.
For the Jedi, The Grandmaster title is almost entirely an honorific. Yoda was a respected individual, but ultimately was just another Master in terms of Knights and Padawans. In terms of his peers, however, he was considered to be the one best suited to run the council. He was the eldest of the Jedi and he had a lot of experience in terms of the force, its applications, and how to be guided by the force. Those qualities would be those looked for in a Master, and thus a Master of Masters.
I would be willing to speculate that the Grandmaster title is a democratically elected or selected individual among the council, just thanks to the structure of the Jedi and the ideals they stood for.
Taekwondo background here. The rank of Master in Kukkiwon TKD can be earned around 4th or 5th dan (it's possible to earn it at 4th dan and more expected at 5th dan that you are a Master). At 7th Dan you can become a Grand Master.
My understanding is that the rank of Grand Master and the higher Dan ranks are more about politics than understanding of the art (because by 5th and 6th Dan you should have a pretty firm understanding of the art, as you've been a black belt for a minimum of 10-15 years by the time you're at that rank). The title of Grand Master gives the elders, those with more wisdom and responsibility, a title above that of Master. It's sort of how in the Army you have Officers and General Officers. The General Officers (O7 and up) are comparable in terms of time-in-grade and necessary education and politicking to be considered senior officers in the Army, a Taekwondo Grandmaster is a Taekwondo practitioner with the necessary education and achievements to be considered a senior leader in the worldwide organization.
Yeah. The title, "Grand Master" has a bad connotation. My base art is Okinawan and the founder of our association is called "Taika" (I think it loosely translates to Grandfather) but when I get blank stares or people confuse the title for his personal name, then I sigh and say "Grand Master." its what people expect to call the leader or founder or whatever. My personal problem with the title is that it implies that there is no more to learn. This person has achieved the ultimate level and cannot learn anything else... which just simply cannot be true.
Sabre: Nobody has done that yet, so ...
Mar 2, 2019 4:38:59 GMT -5
Sabre: LIGHTSABER IS AN OFFICIAL SPORT IN FRANCE !!!
Mar 2, 2019 4:39:13 GMT -5
Furiora Helseare: I know, was crazy for me to see as well, although I'm not a huge fan of the rules... honestly never liked "right of way" in fencing. If people score a double neither should count, you're both dead
Mar 2, 2019 13:57:27 GMT -5
Furiora Helseare: "right of way" doesn't exist in a real fight, I don't care if it's "your turn to attack" if I see an opening I can take, I'm taking it.
Mar 2, 2019 13:58:45 GMT -5
Nero Attoru: Right of way has some roots in realism, since attacking is given priority (which makes sense given the fact that the attacker would theoretically strike a killing blow first)
Mar 6, 2019 16:15:21 GMT -5
Nero Attoru: Regardless, epee is a weapon that most people forget, and doesn't use right of way! Two hits gives each fencer a point, reflecting the double kill.
Mar 6, 2019 16:16:06 GMT -5
cyclingswitch: I get why they went with that system though. If you watch Saber Legion fighting instead, it becomes more akin to kendo. It's realistic fighting but it doesn't look like Star Wars anymore.
Mar 23, 2019 20:34:49 GMT -5
cyclingswitch: In Saber Legion, moving your saber around more than you need to to thrust, parry or do a quick strike to the waist or head is basically giving away a point. At least that's what I've seen in the matches I've watched with their style.
Mar 23, 2019 20:36:10 GMT -5
Colin the Grey: Hey guys, whenever someone can find the time to go over my second Shii-Cho formula primer submission, that'll be a huge help. My free time is going to go down hard in a month or so, and I'd like to make more progress in the meantime. Thanks!
Mar 25, 2019 11:31:16 GMT -5
Furiora Helseare: Hecking fuzz, the amount of spambots as of late.
May 19, 2019 0:05:15 GMT -5
Sabre: ^We will take care of it.
May 20, 2019 12:55:19 GMT -5
Sabre: *** Announcement: Major re-structuring in progress. Please be patient a little while longer! Thanks a lot! ***
May 20, 2019 12:56:44 GMT -5
krawash: Sabre Thank you for the information
May 22, 2019 6:40:43 GMT -5
Sabre: Big Lightsaber Tournament in France this coming weekend! Check "Academie de Sabre Laser!"
Jun 3, 2019 12:44:34 GMT -5
jeanniesbottle: Hello Everyone. I train with the Potsdam Saber Club in Northern New York and just registered.
Sept 7, 2019 15:33:23 GMT -5